Copycat Cracker Barrel’s Vegetable Soup

Copy Cat Cracker Barrel Vegetable Soup Recipe - Comfort Food at it's Best! Homemade, freezer ready, and Delicious! - www.kidfriendlythingstodo.com

It’s Update time! Finally…right?! I’ve had several comments about the vast amount this soup makes. I mean it’s A LOT! When I made this soup, I happened to have a kettle that is able to hold more than the average large pot you might have at home. Understandably, I have received questions about the overwhelming amount. So, while I was on vacation last month in Tennessee (Cracker Barrel’s birthplace!), I played around with the recipe and downsized it. We taste tested it, and it is soooooooooooo goo-ood! It tastes so much like Cracker Barrel’s soup. I was even more excited with the updated version than the first. It’s still A LOT, but you’ll be able to make it on your stove top with your normal extra large pot or large slow cooker. Here’s both versions, enjoy! 

OLD POST: It’s that time of year when I get to go to my sister’s and use her awesome kettle to make soup over a fire! There is nothing like having everyone gathered around a backyard fire with the smell of homemade soup on a crisp fall day.

 

Copy Cat Cracker Barrel Vegetable Soup Recipe - Comfort Food at it's Best! Homemade, freezer ready, and Delicious! - www.kidfriendlythingstodo.com

This time, being in Cracker Barrel Country, I took the opportunity to order vegetable soup the night before I tried the recipe out. I wanted to be able to really compare flavors, plus WE LOVE CRACKER BARREL. Really, we do! It was even on our summer bucket list. Check! Got that one done.

I remember eating the soup that I ordered and thinking, wow..this soup has a strong ground pepper flavor. So, I upped the ground pepper in the new recipe. It really compares, but you’ll definitely want to tone it down from a full teaspoon like I did, and then add more to adjust to your liking. Once you’ve added it, there’s no going back, but you can always add more. I happen to LOVE it, as is and it was pretty spot on from the soup I ordered the night before. 

Copy Cat Cracker Barrel Vegetable Soup Recipe - Comfort Food at it's Best! Homemade, freezer ready, and Delicious! - www.kidfriendlythingstodo.com

The new recipe still makes a lot! I found a large pot in the cabin we stayed in, and measured it. It was between 5 and 6 quarts. Even with my adjustments, it was filled to the tippy-top! You’ll have plenty of left overs to freeze for later.

Copy Cat Cracker Barrel Vegetable Soup Recipe - Comfort Food at it's Best! Homemade, freezer ready, and Delicious! - www.kidfriendlythingstodo.com

Or, you can eat it for 3 days in a row, like we did. 

Here’s the updated recipe that makes roughly 5-6 quarts of soup.

*(If you have a 5 quart pot, hold back on the amount of V8 – add it at the end. You should be able to fit MOST of it. Pour as much as you can to fill your pot. Once you have made the soup, and have scooped out some servings…you can pour the rest in and mix with the rest of the soup. 

Cracker Barrel Copy Cat Vegetable Soup
Serves 10
Write a review
Print
Prep Time
15 min
Cook Time
1 hr
Prep Time
15 min
Cook Time
1 hr
Ingredients
  1. 1 (10 oz.) or small bag of frozen onions
  2. 1 small frozen bag of the following: (about 12 oz. each)
  3. peas
  4. lima beans
  5. corn
  6. 1 can of normal cut green beans with the juices (16 oz.)
  7. 2 (14 oz.) cans of diced tomatoes
  8. 4 beef bouillon cubes
  9. 1 tsp. of salt
  10. 1 tsp. of ground pepper - remember to add less (I'd start with 1/2 tsp.) and then add more for flavor later
  11. 2 celery stalks sliced
  12. 2 large russet potatoes peeled and cubed
  13. 8 cups of water
  14. 32 oz. of Vegetable Juice
Instructions
  1. Pour everything into the pot, stir and bring to a boil.
  2. Lower the temperature to medium - a small boil, and cook for about 1 hour or until potatoes are tender.
Notes
  1. You can also make this in a slow cooker. You'll need to cook it pretty much all day on high to make the potatoes tender enough to enjoy.
  2. Also, don't forget to sign up for my newsletter! And, please like us on Facebook. Have a wonderful day.
Kid Friendly Things to Do.com - Family Recipes, Crafts, and Fun Foods http://kidfriendlythingstodo.com/

 

 Here’s the older soup recipe that makes about 9 quarts of soup:

A copy cat version of Cracker Barrel's Vegetable Soup! Fall comfort food at it's finest. KidFriendlyThingsToDo.com

 This time, I wanted to make the soup I always ask for when we are eating at Cracker Barrel. I love the old fashioned flavor of their vegetable soup. There’s something about it that reminds me of grandma’s homemade soup. It reminds me of the Good Ole’ Days! Here’s the recipe for you to enjoy:

 

You’ll Need:

  • 1 can of V8 (46 oz.)
    3 cans of diced tomatoes (14.5 oz.)
    1 (16 ounce) can green beans
    2 – (12 ounce) pkg frozen corn
    2 – (12 ounce) pkg frozen peas
    2 – (12 ounce) pkg frozen baby lima beans
    1 bag of frozen chopped onions (12-14 oz.)
    1 cup of sliced celery
    1 gallon of water (16 cups)
    6 cubes of beef bullion
    1 lb. idaho potatoes – peeled, and cubed
    Salt and Pepper to taste – I used about 1 Tbsp.  of salt –  I like it on the salty side, so adjust to your preference. 

Now:

  • Just dump it all in together in a large pot, bring to a boil, simmer it down a bit, and let it cook for an hour, or until potatoes are tender! It’s that simple! 

Oh yum! I love, love, love Cracker Barrel's Vegetable Soup. Perfect for campfire soups!

* The Dutch Oven shown is a 9 quart cast iron soup kettle

Adapted from: Spark Recipes

Thank you so much for stopping by. Enjoy!

Here is some equipment that your might need or even want for this recipe:

 

 

~ Melissa – KidFriendlyThingsToDo.com


24 Comments

  1. Thank you for this recipe! I will be attempting to make this tonight. I have one question though, do you drain the canned items or do you include the liquid to help make the broth? Thanks again! ~Whitney

  2. Charlotte Davidson

    The can of V8, is that a 12 oz can?

    • 46 oz. can! It’s the big one! I will go an adjust the recipe to reflect the exact size. Thank you for commenting. I’m sorry you had to ask.

  3. Do the veggies have to be frozen or can they be canned veggies?—equal amounts?

    • The corn, lima beans, and onions are very versatile, so using the canned version is fine for this recipe. They should hold their firmness and texture pretty well.

      *Peas from the can tend to be on the mushy side, and the taste is slightly different. This probably won’t be a huge game changer, but you will notice the difference.
      Definitely “do” use canned beans, as the recipe states. Beans have a noticeable difference in taste and texture from the can. In this soup, you want the “cooked for hours flavor that canned beans can produce”. You also want the juices from the canned beans, which is why you shouldn’t drain the beans.

      But, adding more canned vegetables means more liquid (if you don’t drain). Until I test the soup out with the canned version, I can only guess that all of the liquid from the vegetables might water the soup down a bit. You’ll probably want to drain the added vegetables from the can. If you forget to, and it tastes a bit watered down, add more bullion.

      I hope this helps. I am a huge believer in substituting. Usually, by the end of a recipe half of the recipe has been crossed out, with notes all along the margins. If you get the chance, come back by and let us know how the canned vegetables turned out! πŸ™‚

  4. Donna Wyers

    What size pot do you need I tried to make this in a 8 gt pot and it was not enough room for all the water.

    • What a let down. I’m so sorry. My sister was not sure what the size of her kettle was, so after waiting a couple of days, I went over today to measure it. The kettle holds 9 quarts, but that is to the brim. 8 quarts fit comfortably inside the pot and that is about the level that shows in the picture. An 8 quart pot would work, but the level of liquid will definitely be very close to the top. After the soup cooks down a little, it should fit comfortably.

  5. Have you ever tried to make this in a crockpot? Wondering how that might turn out, don’t have a pot big enough I don’t think…

    • I have not made this in a crock pot, but I think it would be fine. The only finicky ingredient might be the potato. Here are some tips to making sure they come out tender. Make sure the potatoes are completely submerged in liquid and the crock pot is on a high temperature. You’ll want to make sure the temperature is high enough to completely cook the potatoes. Cook the soup for at least 4 hours. Hope this helps. Crock pot meals are always the best!

      • One comment on here says that the soup makes 8 to 9 quarts, and I think most crock pots (at least mine) are only 5 to 6 quarts. Has anyone tried this recipe in a 5 to 6 quart crock pot, and if so, did it work ok?

        • Hi Sandy. I know this has been a concern for a lot of people. I’ll have to try to cut this recipe in half. I think it would be just fine, but I’ll be the Guinea Pig and let you know for sure! πŸ™‚ Look for an update…soon!

          • I did it! I finally updated the recipe and I managed to cut it down to about 5 or 6 quarts. You’ll still have to use your biggest pot in the kitchen, but at least you don’t have to make this in 2 batches, or buy a huge pot for 1 recipe! I have to say…the updated version is better than the original. It was soooooo good, and really stood up to the soup I had at Cracker Barrel the night before I made it. I hope you enjoy it!

  6. Hi this looks so tasty. I’m excited to try it. I’m not much of a fan of celery though, would it work to sub for carrots

    • You could easily just omit the celery. If you wanted to add carrots, they would be a great addition. They are another good “down home” kind of vegetable that’s perfect for this country vegetable soup. πŸ™‚

  7. In the original recipe it calls for a gallon of water so I’m wondering how much the updated recipe needs?

    • What is wrong with me?! I can’t believe I omitted the water portion. Thank you, Thank you for catching this. Yes! You’ll need 8 cups of water.

  8. Karen Richardson

    I madethis yedterday…love it…I love Cracker Barrel vegetable soup.
    I left out the celery…don’t like it. And used 2 cans diced potatoes and instead of a whole bag of peas I used peas and carrots and eliminated the cut carrots.
    Am enjoying some now.
    Thank you…wil make whenever I am craving Cracker Barrel vegetable soup or when the store down the street is out!

  9. Karen Richardson

    I made this yesterday…love it…I love Cracker Barrel vegetable soup.
    I left out the celery…don’t like it. And used 2 cans diced potatoes and instead of a whole bag of peas I used peas and carrots and eliminated the cut carrots.
    Am enjoying some now.
    Thank you…wil make whenever I am craving Cracker Barrel vegetable soup or when the store down the street is out!

  10. Karen Richardson

    And wanted to keep it vegan so I omitted the beef boullion

    • Yay! I’m so glad that you liked it. It’s funny, the last couple of times that I’ve been to Cracker Barrel, they’ve only had vegetable beef. It’s just not the same. I’m so glad we can recreate the vegetable. Thank you for taking the time to let me know that it turned out well for you. Warm Regards, Melissa

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Managed by WebWorksLeela