Old-Fashioned Custard Peanut Butter Pie
This post may contain affiliate links – please read my disclosure statement.
A Peanut Butter Pie with Custard is a delicious combination. Everyone will want your recipes for this delicious homemade and easy-to-make dessert. Add whipped cream or ice cream to a warm slice of this pie, for a bite of heaven.

Custard Peanut Butter Pie
Anything with a custard-and-peanut-butter flavor will bring me running into the kitchen for more. This pie is the best combination of both custard and peanut butter.
Peanut butter makes for such a delicious dessert. Combining custard and peanut butter is just over-the-top on a delicious scale, but that’s just what I did in this recipe. If you make a custard pie like this classic buttermilk pie, you better believe that I want an invitation to that dinner. Of course, no pie is complete without that dollop of whipped cream.
What I love about this recipe:
- Easy to make – using a premade graham cracker crust
- Shortcut Crust – if you want to make this completely homemade then you can easily make a graham cracker crust with just crushed graham crackers and butter
- Satisfying – it is a filling dessert

FAQs About this Baked Peanut Butter Pie
Make Ahead and Storage:
How far in advance can I make this Peanut Butter Pie?
You can make this pie up to 4 days in advance.
Storage: Store this pie covered and in the refrigerator
Reheating: reheat individual slices on a microwave-proof dish in the microwave
Freezing: It is not recommended to freeze this custard pie. Custard tends to separate when frozen which will impact the texture
What is Peanut Butter Pie Made Of?
This old-fashioned peanut butter pie is made of corn syrup, peanut butter, sugar, salt, eggs, almond extract, and a graham cracker crust
How do you know when a Custard Pie is Done?
- The outside circumference should be done
- The middle will remain jiggly
- The middle should not be runny
- A knife inserted should be mostly clean
Melissa’s Tips and Tricks:
- use a pre-made graham cracker crust for an easy shortcut
- use a chocolate graham cracker crust for a delicious Reese’s flavor, or use an Oreo crust for an alternative
- you can make a homemade graham cracker crust for a completely homemade pie
- delicious when served with whipped cream (whipped topping) or a scoop of vanilla ice cream
- drizzle chocolate syrup for Reese’s peanut butter cup flavor
- crumble Oreos on top for an added topping
- chill pie in the refrigerator until ready to eat
- place foil over crust to prevent browning
Ingredients for this Peanut Butter Pie

- pre-made graham cracker crust
- light corn syrup – you can substitute dark corn syrup
- granulated sugar
- creamy peanut butter – I used a reduced fat peanut butter, but that’s just because that is my preference
- salt – just plain table salt is recommended for this recipe
- almond extract – you can use vanilla extract instead if that is all you have or if you do not like the almond flavor
How to Make a Peanut Butter Pie?
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees
- Using a large mixing bowl and a whisk or electric mixer, mix the corn syrup, sugar, peanut butter, and salt together
- Beat in the eggs and the almond extract
- Pour the peanut butter mixture into the prepared pie crust
- Place pie on a baking sheet
- Bake for about 1 hour, or until the top has risen, and the middle is about to set
- Serve warm or chill until ready
More Pie Recipes

Old Fashioned Custard Peanut Butter Pie
Ingredients
- 1 graham cracker pie crust 9 inch
- 1&1/2 cups light corn syrup
- ½ cup granulated sugar
- ½ cup creamy peanut butter
- ¼ tsp. salt
- 4 large eggs
- ½ tsp. almond extract
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees
- Using a large mixing bowl and a whisk or electric mixer, mix the corn syrup, sugar, peanut butter, and salt together
- Beat in the eggs and the almond extract
- Pour peanut butter mixture into the prepared pie crust
- Place pie on a baking sheet
- Bake for about 1 hour, or until the top has risen, and the middle is about to set
- Serve warm or chill until ready
Notes
nutrition facts are only an estimateÂ
Storage: Store this pie covered and in the refrigeratorHow do you know when a Custard Pie is Done?
- The outside circumference should be done
- The middle will remain jiggly
- The middle should not be runny
- A knife inserted should be mostly clean
Nutrition


